I have to say that this is just about the only brand of wet foods that all four of my cats will agree upon eating. So, YES, I do know all about finicky eaters! I do feed them dry food and it's set out as free choice food, I give them this to suppliment their diet and give them a little something tasty. They each get 1/2 of a three ounce can, once in the morning and once in the evening, and they love it. Although each one kind of leans in a bit more in different taste and texture directions, there is a flavor and texture for everyone. From poultry, beef, and seafood, to chopped, grilled, sliced, minced, roasted, marinated morsels, flaked, and with OR without gravy! So if you have a finicky one at home, I'm sure that there is bound to be something tasty here for your fussy furry companion too!