Sometimes I think I'd rather just go to bed with my makeup on and wake up with crusty eyeliner than use this to remove my makeup. The Almay oil free products dry my skin out so much that I need to apply moisturizer afterwards but they still act light enough that it feels like a simple toner. The oil based products feel like I just ate a bucket of buttered popcorn and rubbed my hands all over my face. That feeling remains all night and it just feels too thick. When I get up in the morning, I just wake up with oily eyelids. I still have a bottle of oil-free stashed away just in case I run out of facial toner; which also doubles as a great make up remover (not astringent because it's not good for the eyes) but for the most part, I'm straying away from the oil based products.