I lived in Columbus Ohio for a few years and had a regular subscription to the Columbus Dispatch.
I was really impressed by the quality of there writing. The business section was a flat out pleasure to read every day. I am not kidding, I found it on top of all current issues, and right on for the most part.
I was also a HUGE fan of the Sunday paper. There home and garden section offered a lot of insight, not only on the Columbus housing market, but on what people are doing with their homes in leu of moving. The coupon section was not bad either.
My only complaint was there billing department. We cancelled our subscription because we moved, and they kept sending our paper and billing us? I guess you can't have everything!