If you haven't heard of or tried out eyeslipsface cosmetics, also known as e.l.f., this is a good product to start with. e.l.f.'s products are almost all priced at $1.00 and they are never tested on animals. Since the products are so cheap, there are, of course, some products that are better than the others. This eyeliner is a terrific product.
I purchased this product for $1.00 online (along with other products from the store). I chose the "ash" color, a dark gray. The product is also available in black, coffee, midnight, and plum. After the success I had with the ash color, I will purchase the coffee and plum colors next.
This product is really easy to apply, which is good for me, because my hands aren't steady enough to do well with some eyeliners. The tip is very fine, but with the somewhat liquid feel of the liner, it goes on with a thick enough line. For a bolder look, you can always go over the eyes with the eyeliner again.
I was amazed with how long this stayed on my eyes. I put it on around 8:00 am and it lasted until about 10:00 pm when I was ready to take it off. It never smudged or creased, and it looked nice with the lavender eye shadow I had on with it.
I would definitely recommend this product as a bargain; not only is it cheap, but the color looks nice, it is easy to apply, and it lasts all day.