I have had these winter boots for over a year. I needed something warm to work outside in the snow, something sturdy and not too heavy / bulky. These Herman Survivor boots fit the bill. I also liked the pull-on design - no strings or zippers, just pull the boots on and go.
The boots turned out to be very warm, excellent for cold winter. I only use them in the coldest weather - otherwise, my feet feel too hot and start sweating. The boots have cushioned footbed, but I have to say that at first they were not very comfortable. They are rather tough, which is good for durability, but this hardness made them hard on the feet too; it took me about two months of wearing to soften them up enough and get used to them. I putin a soft insole, and it helped a lot. After about two months though, the boots feel and wear great.