Over all, my experience with this gel eyeliner has been a good one. This particular color called Nightfall is a cognac/burgundy color The price cannot be beat at $10 however, I found that sometimes, the liner will dry out in the little pot which can be an inconvenience because it's harder to get the right amount on the brush. On the positive side, I have oily eyelids & once I put the liner on, it stays on all day until I take it off. I also like the fact that the liner is in a little pot but don't let the size of the pot deceive you-the liner will last a very long time! I hope that they will add more colors of the eyeliners because right now, they have a limited selection to choose from.