Peerless Insurance has worked for us for many years. We are able to call and talk to agents that are right within a few miles of our home. They give very friendly service, and are always willing to try to settle any claims as soon as possible. Our agent is quick to give us options that are in our best interest. She gets an A+ from us.
I'm not certain they are considered the cheapest insurance, but they have always made us feel like they can settle any of our claims or questions. Even though we haven't had many claims, we don't feel we need to worry about any cancellation of our policy if we did put in a claim.
Go with Peerless and you can't go wrong. I will rate them a 10 and a thumbs up.