This is the first edible product that I have purchased for my pets that they did not like! I was shocked and disappointed, I usually buy the Pet Tabs, but this time I wanted to try these because they were cute, the vitamins are in the shape of people, the milkman, the animal control officer and the mailman. My dogs will not touch them. I breed miniature dachshunds and when I have one who is expecting a litter I make sure they have vitamins during and after delivery, I have learned not to buy this brand. To top off my disappointment, these are made by Sergent. Usually everything I purchase from them is excellent quality. If it had only been one or two of my dogs that did not like these I would not care, but it is all 15 that turned their noses up at them. I do not recommend these to anyone.