I recently tried Tide with Bleach Alternative, the Color Safe type, for my clothes. I really liked the way it worked, and it was completely safe for my dark clothing. I especially like the scent, Mountain Spring, which lingered on my clothes and made them smell just great.
One problem with the scent, though. When my husband put on a shirt that I had recently washed in this detergent, he didn't like the lingering scent. He thought it smelled like perfume. I thought the clothes smelled fine, but of course, I'm looking at it from a woman's perspectiv
I purchased it in the 50 fl oz size, which would do about 26 loads. The Tide with Bleach Alternative that I had was 2x Ultra, and I was very pleased with the way my clothes looked and smelled after using it. This detergent also contains no phosphate.
I would definitely like to use Tide with Bleach Alternative Color Safe again. After my husband made that one remark about the scent, he never remarked about it again, so I guess it was no longer a problem for him. I think the scent is great, and the detergent's washing ability did not let me down.