I recently bought some Black Radiance eyeliner made by Wet n Wild. This product was inexpensive to buy and comes in a variety or colors and shades. When I used this product the eyeliner did come on very black like I wanted it to. I did like that part about this product. What I did not like was the fact that the eyeliner did not stay on very long and it would fade and smudge quickly. The product also had some smearing issues. When I would work up a sweat at all, it would smear really bad. I don't like products that can't hold up to daily life. I like to be able to wear my eyeliner all day. I did not like the fact I would have to keep reapplying this eyeliner several times a day. I would only use this product as an inexpensive, quick fix . This eyeliner is very cheap and I know you can not expect alot from cheap eyeliner. Overall, his eyeliner was ok but I think I will only use this product when I have nothing else to use.